Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN Surfshark VPN is an exceptional choice for individuals who frequently stream across the globe, as it offers a combination of reliable protection, access to content that is restricted by location, and the convenience of using worldwide servers.
Surfshark provides competitive pricing, starting at $1.99 per month (billed every two years), and additional features that make it an ideal choice for frequent travelers, all while maintaining reliable connections, even when multiple devices are connected simultaneously.
In the interim, users who are cost-conscious and in search of a fundamental VPN for browsing and security may find Total VPN to be more than adequate. It offers fundamental encryption and efficacy at a starting price of $1.59 per month (billed annually) for the initial year.
This head-to-head comparison provides additional information regarding their server capabilities, pricing options, and features. Please continue reading to learn more about Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN.
Contents
- 1 Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN at a glance
- 2 How we test and rate VPNs
- 3 Surfshark VPN pros and cons
- 4 Total VPN pros and cons
- 5 Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN: Prices
- 6 Which VPN is faster?
- 7 Which VPN is more secure?
- 8 Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN: Compatibility and customer support
- 9 Is Surfshark VPN or Total VPN better?
- 10 Dedicated Apps
- 11 Conclusion
- 12 FAQs
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN at a glance
Surfshark VPN is an exceptional option for travelers and streaming enthusiasts who require dependable speeds and unlimited device connections when comparing the most popular virtual private network (VPN) services. However, Total VPN is a cost-effective alternative that provides fundamental security features, such as robust encryption, without any additional fees.
- Surfshark VPN: Best for travel and streaming
- Total VPN: Best for a budget
How do Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN compare?
| Price | From $1.99/mo (billed every two years) | From $1.59/mo (billed annually) for the first year |
|---|---|---|
| Max # of connected devices | Unlimited | 5 |
| 24/7 customer support | ||
| Compatibility | Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Fire TV, and Android TV | Windows, macOS, Android, iOS |
| # of servers | 3,200+ servers in 100 countries | 50 servers in 30+ countries |
| VPN protocol | WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN | OpenVPN, IKEv2 |
| No-logs policy | No logs | No logs |
| Unblocks Netflix? | ||
| Learn more | Get Surfshark VPN Read Surfshark VPN Review | Get Total VPN Read Total VPN Review |
How we test and rate VPNs
We administer standardized hands-on exams to each VPN that we evaluate in order to evaluate their claims. This encompasses rigorous third-party testing, which involves comparing our internet performance while connected to various servers, verifying the functionality of the kill switch, and identifying any potential DNS leaks. We also ensure that we can access popular streaming sites, such as Netflix, without interruption while continuing to conduct our daily tasks.
Our editorial rating is determined by evaluating the key features that are indicative of a high-quality product after the testing has been finalized. We evaluate each VPN based on the following categories and employ a weighted average to determine the final rating out of 5 stars: price, server count, performance, security, and features.
Surfshark VPN pros and cons
Surfshark VPN is one of the most effective VPNs for streaming, whether you are browsing the internet at a cafe or viewing movies on Netflix during a lengthy international flight. The reason for this is that it protects your data with the highest level of encryption, AES-256-GCM, which is a step above the standard AES-256. This is achieved through the use of built-in authentication and enhanced encryption.
It enhances security and provides high server speeds by utilizing rapid and robust protocols such as WireGuard with ChaCha20 encryption, IKEv2, and OpenVPN.
Surfshark VPN’s capacity to facilitate an infinite number of concurrent connections is another noteworthy feature, rendering it an optimal choice for individuals with a diverse array of devices or a large family.
Surfshark not only offers kill switch and split tunneling capabilities but also includes Smart DNS, a dedicated IP, antivirus, a rotating IP, and a NoBorders feature for global accessibility.
It comprises CleanWeb 2.0, which serves to prevent malware, trackers, and advertisements. Additionally, we valued the fact that the organization provides email and live chat support that is available 24/7.
Although Surfshark boasts a vast server network of over 3,200 servers in 100 countries and a plethora of high-quality features, we are not particularly enamored of the fact that the company is headquartered in the Netherlands, which is a member of the Nine Eyes alliance.
Nevertheless, we acknowledge the fact that its stringent no-logs policy has been effectively audited by Deloitte in a recent and independent manner. This demonstrates Surfshark VPN’s dedication to privacy and transparency.
Additionally, Surfshark VPN has not experienced a data compromise or disclosed any of its customers’ private information.
Pros
- Strong encryption
- Allows simultaneous connections on an infinite number of devices
- Smart DNS feature bypasses geo-blocks for streaming
Cons
- Antivirus, threat monitoring, and a dedicated IP cost extra
- Headquartered in the Nine Eyes a
Total VPN pros and cons
Although Total VPN is reasonably priced at $1.59 per month (billed annually) for the initial year, it provides fundamental protection through the use of AES-256 encryption and robust protocols such as OpenVPN and IKEv2.
Total VPN, an integral part of TotalAV’s comprehensive security bundle, provides additional antivirus and ad filtering capabilities to protect online activity.
Additionally, it incorporates Total Adblock to safeguard your device from online hazards and block advertisements.
Total VPN is exceptional in terms of its user-friendliness and fundamental internet security. If you require a VPN for fundamental browsing and security without the inclusion of additional features, this is an excellent option. It does not provide protection for an infinite number of devices, as Surfshark does; however, it does support up to five simultaneous connections.
Our speed evaluations indicate that it is somewhat fast, but not exceptional, with specific slowdowns observed on long-distance servers.
Regrettably, the server selection is rather limited, with 50 servers in over 30 countries. Furthermore, Total VPN does not offer split tunneling, which enables your device to route a portion of its traffic through the VPN.
Finally, it is situated in the United Kingdom, which is a member of the Five Eyes surveillance alliance. Its data collection practices are concerning, as it collects utilization activity and shares users’ data with third parties in accordance with its privacy policy.
Pros
- Affordable pricing
- Includes antivirus and ad blocker (TotalAV and Total Adblock)
- Easy to use
Cons
- Limited server network
- No split tunneling
- Headquartered in the Five Eyes alliance
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN: Prices
| Price range | $1.99–$17.95/mo | $1.59/mo |
|---|---|---|
| Best value plan | Surfshark One plan for $2.49/mo (billed every two years) | Ultimate VPN plan for $1.59/mo (billed annually) for the first year |
| Money-back guarantee | Yes — 30 days | Yes — 30 days |
| Learn more | Get Surfshark VPN Read Surfshark VPN Review | Get Total VPN Read Total VPN Review |
Surfshark VPN provides a more extensive price range when comparing VPN costs, with a beginning price of $1.99 per month (billed every two years) and a maximum price of $1.99 per month (billed every two years)…
Surfshark VPN’s One plan is a standout option for those who are interested in a well-rounded combination of affordability and functionality. This plan is priced at $2.49 per month and is invoiced every two years. Additionally, it includes a comprehensive list of features.
Simultaneously, Total VPN’s most expensive plan, the Ultimate VPN, offers an unparalleled introductory price of $1.59 per month (billed annually) for the initial year, which is significantly lower than its competitors.
Additionally, both VPNs offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, which allows for risk-free testing of their services. This evaluation period is prudent for individuals who are uncertain and wish to thoroughly assess their capabilities prior to enrolling in a subscription plan.
Although Surfshark’s premium packages include ad blocking and malware protection, which render the higher fees more palatable, Total VPN’s lower costs make fundamental protection accessible to those on a budget.
Payment options
Both Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN offer a variety of payment options, ensuring flexibility and convenience.
Surfshark VPN payment options
- Credit or debit card
- PayPal
- Google Pay
- Amazon Pay
- Sofort
- Cryptocurrency through CoinGate (Bitcoin, Ethereum, Dogecoin, etc.)
Total VPN payment options
- Credit or debit card
- PayPal
Winner: With its versatile plans, robust security features, and acceptance of various payment methods, Surfshark VPN emerges as the clear winner.
Which VPN is faster?
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN Testing the download speed of each VPN is crucial to understanding their performance impact on your internet connection. We tested both VPNs using a Windows laptop based in the USA.
This table shows the percentage slowdown in internet speed when connected to different servers:
| Server location | Our Pick | Total VPN |
|---|---|---|
| US | -3.55% (slower) | -15.53% (slower) |
| Canada | -8.60% (slower) | -44.74% (slower) |
| UK | -9.14% (slower) | -42.79% (slower) |
| AU | -33.83% (slower) | -51.73% (slower) |
| Learn more | Get Surfshark VPN Read Surfshark VPN Review | Get Total VPN Read Total VPN Review |
Surfshark consistently outperformed Total VPN, particularly on servers that were located at a greater distance from the test location. Surfshark is an optimal option for bandwidth-intensive activities such as streaming due to its minimal impact on speed.
Winner: Surfshark is the fastest VPN, offering significantly better performance across all tested locations.
Which VPN is more secure?
| Feature | Our Pick | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of servers | 3,200+ servers in 100 countries | 50 servers in 30+ countries |
| No-logs policy | No logs | Yes, logs user activity |
| VPN headquarters | Netherlands | U.K. |
| Encryption | AES-256-GCM | AES-256 |
| VPN protocol | WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN | OpenVPN, IKEv2 |
| Kill switch | ||
| Split tunneling | ||
| DNS leak protection | ||
| Ad blocker | ||
| Learn more | Get Surfshark VPN Read Surfshark VPN Review | Get Total VPN Read Total VPN Review |
A kill switch is offered by both VPNs, which ensures that your IP address is never exposed in the event of a VPN connection failure. This feature disconnects your internet. Additionally, DNS leak protection is accessible on both platforms, which safeguards your anonymity by preventing DNS requests from escaping outside the VPN tunnel.
They both employ robust protocols; however, Surfshark has an advantage by employing AES-256-GCM encryption (an enhanced variant of the standard AES-256) and the more modern, secure, and efficient VPN protocol, WireGuard.
Moreover, Surfshark’s server network, which spans over 3,200 servers, surpasses that of Total VPN, which has a mere 50 servers. This allows for quicker speeds and the effortless circumvention of geo-blocks.
Additionally, it provides a dedicated IP address to improve access to restricted content and boost streaming experiences.
Surfshark, in addition, offers a variety of security features, including a double VPN (multi-hop), split tunneling, a NoBorders feature for circumventing stringent regional restrictions, and Clean Web 2.0 for blocking ads and trackers.Total VPN does not offer an audited no-logs policy, whereas Surfshark’s policy demonstrates a dedication to online privacy. Surfshark’s headquarters are situated in a Nine Eyes country; however, there have been no allegations of the company disclosing user data to authorities.
In the same vein, Total VPN is based in the United Kingdom, which is a member of the Five Eyes alliance. It collaborates with the Nine Eyes, as it participates in intelligence sharing with its allied nations. Nevertheless, there is no indication that Total VPN has disclosed user information to law enforcement.
A comprehensive examination of Total VPN’s privacy policy uncovered alarming details, including the permissible accumulation of usage activity and the sharing of data with external entities. Additionally, the no-logs policy is not enforced by a third-party audit.
Winner: Surfshark is the frontrunner, offering top-notch encryption and double VPN protection, thus securing users’ data and online activity.
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN: Compatibility and customer support
| Our Pick | ||
|---|---|---|
| Windows | ||
| macOS | ||
| Android | ||
| iOS | ||
| Linux | ||
| Routers | ||
| Smart devices | ||
| Browser extensions | Yes — Chrome, Firefox, Edge | |
| 24/7 customer support | ||
| Customer support options | Live chat, email, online guides | Live chat, online guides |
| Learn more | Get Surfshark VPN Read Surfshark VPN Review | Get Total VPN Read Total VPN Review |
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN The VPN functionality of Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN is essential for a variety of devices, as they both support major operating systems such as Windows, macOS, Android, and iOS.
Surfshark enhances its compatibility by incorporating Linux, routers, and smart devices, enabling users to more comprehensively secure their complete home networks and connect a wider variety of devices.
Furthermore, Surfshark’s extensions for Chrome, Firefox, and Edge optimize the browsing experience, rendering it highly convenient for daily online activities.
Surfshark’s user interface is also highly intuitive, making it suitable for both novice and seasoned users. It enables the rapid access to sophisticated features, such as a kill switch and split tunneling, as well as the effortless establishment of server connections.
Conversely, Total VPN is compatible with its primary platforms; however, it does not possess Surfshark’s extensive compatibility. It does not provide support for Linux, routers, smart devices, or any browser extensions, which could potentially restrict its utility for individuals who are in search of a more comprehensive and adaptable VPN solution.
Is Surfshark VPN or Total VPN better?
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN Due to its extensive server network and superior security features such as AES-256-GCM encryption, WireGuard, smart DNS, split tunneling, and exceptional 24/7 live chat support, Surfshark VPN emerges as the clear winner.
Its dedication to user data privacy has been underscored by the recent successful audit of its no-logs policy. Surfshark is the optimal VPN for travelers, streaming enthusiasts, and those seeking comprehensive online privacy.
On the other hand, Total VPN is a more cost-effective alternative that offers military-grade encryption, robust protocols, a kill switch, and Total AV antivirus, and Total Adblock. This renders it appropriate for fundamental browsing and security requirements.
Nevertheless, Surfshark VPN is the superior option due to its extensive server network, sophisticated features, vetted no-logs policy, and broader platform support, as opposed to Total VPN’s limited server count and questionable data collection practices.
Dedicated Apps
Your hardware is the primary focus of TotalVPN. It can be executed on a desktop computer, laptop, tablet, and mobile device. In the interim, Surfshark provides supplementary coverage for streaming devices, including Apple TV and FireTV, and smart TVs. It is also possible to configure it on your router to safeguard all devices that are connected to the Wi-Fi. The applications for both VPNs are summarized below.
| Device | TotalVPN | Surfshark |
|---|---|---|
| Chrome | No | Yes |
| iOS | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Android | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | No | Yes |
| FireTV | No | Yes |
| Firefox | No | Yes |
| Edge | No | Yes |
| Apple TV | No | Yes |
Conclusion
Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN In 2025, Surfshark VPN vs. Total VPN both provide robust privacy and security features; however, Surfshark is distinguished by its advanced encryption methods, extensive server network, and consistent performance. Surfshark offers exceptional value for both casual users and those who prioritize comprehensive online security, thanks to its user-friendly interface, ad-blocking, and unlimited device connections. Surfshark is the superior choice for individuals who prioritize privacy and efficacy in the long term, despite the fact that Total VPN offers competitive pricing. This is due to Surfshark’s more comprehensive features and higher reliability.
FAQs
What distinguishes Surfshark VPN from Total VPN?
Surfshark provides a more extensive server network, advanced features such as CleanWeb (ad-blocking), and unrestricted simultaneous device connections. Total VPN is a more straightforward option, but it may be appealing to users who are seeking a cost-effective alternative without a wide range of features.
Is Surfshark VPN a more worthwhile investment than Total VPN?
Yes, Surfshark offers a superior overall experience, including a broader selection of server locations, more dependable speeds, and improved security features. It is the optimal choice for users who require a user-friendly interface and more robust privacy tools.
Which VPN provides the highest level of security?
Compared to Total VPN, which may offer fewer encryption options and security features, Surfshark is distinguished by its strict no-logs policy and utilization of the most recent encryption protocols (AES-256-GCM).
Is it possible to utilize Surfshark VPN or Total VPN on multiple devices?
Surfshark is an ideal choice for families or individuals with numerous devices, as it permits the use of an unlimited number of devices with a single subscription. Connections are typically restricted by Total VPN, which may be a hindrance for residences with multiple devices or those with a larger population.